Is CA Perfume Black Musk a dupe of Montale Black Musk?

Black Musk EDP

Montale by Pierre Montale Original Acquired

Black Musk Oil

CA Perfume   Inspired Statement
Share
Card A shareable image comparing these two fragrances - verdicts, profiles and what they share. Save or copy it to post anywhere.
Black Musk Eau de Parfum bottle Black Musk EDP
EDP Concentration Oil
U Gender F
2010 Year -
$$ Price Tier $
Black Musk Perfume Oil bottle Black Musk Oil
$70.69+ tax from
3.4 fl oz (100 ml) at FragranceNet
Buy Black Musk Check price on →
No stockist yet
We have not found it at a shop we track that delivers to you
Check price on →

Where they differ

Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.

ScentArt

Black Musk Eau de Parfum ScentArt View Liquid → Black Musk EDP
Black Musk Perfume Oil ScentArt View Liquid → Black Musk Oil

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Black Musk EDP
Black Musk is a potent, polarising Montale classic. It's often compared to other 'Black' Montales, sharing that distinctive DNA. Expect beast-mode performance, a dark, leathery character, and a love-it-or-hate-it musk that some find intoxicatingly sexy, others utterly repulsive. Definitely not a blind buy.
Acquired
Our Verdict - Black Musk Oil
Warm musk and leather give way to dry spice, sandalwood, amber and patchouli.
Statement

Scent Profile

How they compare
Black Musk EDP A Black Musk Oil B
Where they part company by gap size

How They Wear

Showing: Overall Blend

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Black Musk EDP
Black Musk Oil

Notes

Shared Notes
Musk Musk 22% vs 12%
Leather Leather 18% vs 13%
Patchouli Patchouli 11% vs 12%
Pepper Pepper 11% vs 13%
Sandalwood Sandalwood 10% vs 12%
Amber Amber 9% vs 13%
Nutmeg Nutmeg 8% vs 11%
Teak Teak 6% vs 10%

Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.

Performance

Black Musk Black Musk
Long (6-10h)
Longevity
Moderate (4-6h)
Strong
Projection
Intimate
Strong
Intensity
Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Black Musk

Seasons

Best For:
Autumn Winter
Also Works:
Spring

A cold-weather scent - best worn in winter and autumn.

Occasions

Also Works:
Date Casual Formal

Its potent projection and distinct musky-leather profile make it too intense for the office. It's perfectly suited for cooler evenings, particularly dates or formal events where its commanding yet intimate nature can shine without overwhelming. Not a casual or sport fragrance by any stretch.

Black Musk

Seasons

Best For:
Autumn Winter

Musk and sandalwood soften the leather and spice, making the scent easier in mild spring as well as autumn. The amber and patchouli base still favours cooler weather over summer heat.

Occasions

Also Works:
Date Casual

The smooth sandalwood gives the leather and musk a more relaxed edge for casual plans. Pepper, amber and patchouli keep it fitting for an evening, while the darker base feels less at home in sport or a quiet office.

Similarity Breakdown

Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.

Overall scent match
91%
Key Similarities

Every one of its 8 notes is in the original, including Leather, Musk, Pepper

Key Differences

Near-identical note list, differs in proportion

Where to buy

Black Musk EDP
Black Musk Oil

Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS