Fragrances inspired by Vanilla Cake Eau de Parfum

The original Vanilla Cake Montale
Inspired by M423 Palermo Perfumes
Full comparison Not sold in the United States

The two side by side

ScentArt fingerprint for Vanilla Cake
ScentArt fingerprint for M423
93%

Our verdict

Editor reviewed

What they share

Every one of its 5 notes is in the original, including Almond, Milk, Caramel

The main difference

Near-identical note list, differs in proportion

What they share

Shares 4 of its 5 notes, including Milk, Meringue, Almond

The main difference

Adds vanilla, drops frosting [glacé]

What they share

Shares 4 of its 5 notes, including Almond, Caramel, Milk

The main difference

Adds vanilla, drops frosting [glacé]

What they share

Shares 2 of its 5 notes, including Milk, Vanilla

The main difference

Adds almond and caramel, drops heliotrope and sugar cane

What they share

Shares 2 of its 5 notes, including Almond, Vanilla

The main difference

Adds caramel and meringue, drops butter and cinnamon

What they share

Shares 2 of its 5 notes, including Vanilla, Caramel

The main difference

Adds almond and meringue, drops amber and biscuit

What they share

Shares 1 of its 5 notes, including Vanilla

The main difference

Adds almond and caramel, drops cupcake

What they share

Shares 3 of its 5 notes, including Vanilla, Caramel, Milk

The main difference

Adds almond and meringue, drops amber and cedar

Scent profile

Vanilla Cake EDP the original M423 EDP inspired by

Open the full side-by-side comparison

How we judge a match

We score each pairing on the two fragrance profiles: shared accords, overlapping notes, longevity and projection, and the occasions each suits. A good inspired-by scent captures the original's character rather than copying it molecule for molecule.

The full method, and what to look for in a dupe. Prices come from shops that deliver to you and change often. Check before buying.