Is HK PERFUMES Lady Musk a dupe of Montale Roses Musk?

Roses Musk EDP

Montale by Pierre Montale Original Statement

Lady Musk Extrait

HK PERFUMES   Inspired Favourite
Share
Card A shareable image comparing these two fragrances - verdicts, profiles and what they share. Save or copy it to post anywhere.
Roses Musk Eau de Parfum bottle Roses Musk EDP
EDP Concentration Extrait
F Gender F
2009 Year -
$$ Price Tier $
Lady Musk Extrait bottle Lady Musk Extrait
$80.99+ tax from
3.4 fl oz (100 ml) at Maple Prime
Buy Roses Musk Check price on →
$64.00+ tax from
3.4 fl oz (100 ml) at HK Perfumes
Buy Lady Musk Check price on →

Where they differ

Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.

ScentArt

Roses Musk Eau de Parfum ScentArt View Liquid → Roses Musk EDP
Lady Musk Extrait ScentArt View Liquid → Lady Musk Extrait

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Roses Musk EDP
A juicy rose pressed against a clean, heavy musk, with creamy jasmine in the middle. Straightforward, commanding and strong, and the kind of scent that tells you straight away whether you like it.
Statement
Our Verdict - Lady Musk Extrait
A delicate rose pairs with clean, soft musk. The rose gives the scent a clear floral outline, while the musk keeps the finish light and soft.
Favourite

Scent Profile

How they compare
Roses Musk EDP A Lady Musk Extrait B
Where they part company by gap size

How They Wear

Showing: Overall Blend

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Roses Musk EDP
Lady Musk Extrait

Notes

Shared Notes
Rose Rose 44% vs 52%
Musk Musk 36% vs 47%

Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.

Performance

Roses Musk Lady Musk
Long (6-10h)
Longevity
Moderate (4-6h)
Strong
Projection
Intimate
Strong
Intensity
Light

Season and Occasion Fit

Roses Musk

Seasons

Best For:
Spring
Also Works:
Summer Autumn Winter

Rose is at its freshest in spring, and the musk keeps it wearable through summer and autumn. It stays comfortable in winter too, because the musk gives it body.

Occasions

Also Works:
Date Casual Formal

High projection and strong lasting power make it too much for the office. Date nights are where it shines, and it adds a confident touch to casual outings and dressy events.

Lady Musk

Seasons

Best For:
Spring
Also Works:
Summer

Rose gives the scent a light floral shape and the dew-like sweetness suits spring and mild summer days. Clean musk brings enough softness for autumn, but the airy character has little weight for cold winter weather.

Occasions

Also Works:
Office Date Casual Formal

Rose adds a gentle lift for daytime or a relaxed date, while clean musk keeps the scent soft enough for everyday wear. It is less suited to sport or formal occasions.

Similarity Breakdown

Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.

Overall scent match
89%
Key Similarities

Shares 2 of its 3 notes, including Musk, Rose

Key Differences

Adds jasmine

Where to buy

Roses Musk EDP
Lady Musk Extrait

Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS