This Maceration Station mystery is either a boozy, sweet powerhouse or a fleeting whiff of disappointment, depending on the bottle, the batch, and when you sniff it. If you get a good one, expect an Angel's Share clone that actually performs; otherwise, you'll be left wanting more.

This is Montale's attempt at the quintessential gourmand vanilla and it's a divisive one. Fans love the rich, sweet, and comforting scent, with some calling it 'the' vanilla. Detractors, however, find it synthetic, plasticky, and cloying. Approach with caution, but if you want to smell like cookies, this might be your jam.