Dupes for Mystery Tobacco Eau de Parfum

8 affordable alternatives - from £2

Original

This is a real head-turner, divisive for its price point and comparisons to other tobacco heavy hitters but praised for its smooth, sophisticated blend. It's a must-try for serious tobacco lovers, but prepare your wallet.

Acquired

→

Fragrances below are inspired by Mystery Tobacco Eau de Parfum. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, or produced by Carolina Herrera.

Known dupes

Both lean woody, tobacco, sweet

Subtle differences in overall composition

Mystery Tobacco and Exclusif Tabac share a strong resemblance, but the key difference lies in their intensity and price.

Choose this when You want a powerful, long-lasting tobacco fragrance.

Compare View

£12 Save £50

Both lean woody, tobacco, patchouli

Subtle differences in overall composition

Mystery Tobacco (A) and Charuto Mysterious Tobacco (B) are strikingly similar, with Charuto being a clear dupe.

Choose this when You want an affordable alternative to Mystery Tobacco.

Buy £12 Compare View

£7 Save £55

Both lean woody, sweet, warm spicy

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £7 Compare View

Also smells similar

£5 Save £57

Both lean tobacco, sweet, vanilla

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £5 Compare View

£15 Save £48

Both lean tobacco, sweet, vanilla

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £15 Compare View

£7 Save £55

Both lean woody, sweet, aromatic

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £7 Compare View

£2 Save £60

Both lean warm spicy, sweet, woody

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £2 Compare View

£55 Save £7

Both lean sweet, aromatic, woody

Subtle differences in overall composition

Buy £55 Compare View

What makes a good dupe?

A good dupe captures the essence of the original fragrance - the same mood, the key accords, the general character - at a more accessible price point. It doesn't need to be a molecule-for-molecule copy. The best dupes feel right for the same occasions and carry a similar energy, giving you more ways to enjoy a scent profile you love.

We assess dupes by comparing the fragrance profile of the original against the dupe: shared accords, overlapping notes, similar longevity and projection, and occasion suitability. Our similarity scores reflect how closely the two fragrances align in character - not just raw ingredients.

For a deeper look at how dupes work and what to look for, read our complete guide to perfume dupes.

Price savings shown are based on current UK retail prices and may change. Always check the latest prices before purchasing.