5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon Eau de Parfum vs Fleur de Murier Eau de Parfum

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

Edp	Concentration	Edp
U	Gender	U
2013	Year	2018
££	Price Tier	££

Fleur de Murier

ScentArt

A

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

B

Fleur de Murier

Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - 5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

A modern classic that’s been cruelly cancelled. This effortlessly elegant, fruity-floral vanilla is a people-pleaser, proving quality needn’t break the bank. Some find it a bit ‘meh’ and synthetic, but for most, it's a comforting, sophisticated daily wear.

Favourite

Our Verdict - Fleur de Murier

This one's a bit of a curveball. Karl Lagerfeld's Fleur de Murier is a divisive take on fruity florals, with its unexpectedly tart and woody dry down sparking a 'love it or leave it' response amongst wearers. Not for everyone, but certainly not boring.

Favourite

Scent Profile

Citrus	8%	9%
Floral	24%	21%
Fruity	30%	30%
Green	8%	3%
Sweet	35%	33%
Warm	5%	5%
Woody	5%	8%
Earthy	2%	3%
Animalic	7%	9%
Fresh	16%	15%

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon EdP

Fleur de Murier EdP

Notes

Only in 5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

Peach 49% Apple 27% Bergamot 24%

Only in Fleur de Murier

Red Currant 39% Raspberry 36% Orange 24%

Only in 5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

Peony 29% Blackcurrant 26% Jasmine 24% Plum Blossom 21%

Only in Fleur de Murier

Blackberry 32% Violet 26% Orange Blossom 22% Lily Of The Valley 20%

Shared Notes

Vanilla 25% vs 22%

Musk 21% vs 31%

Sandalwood 16% vs 26%

Amber 14% vs 20%

Only in 5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

Tonka Bean 22%

Accords

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon Fleur de Murier

100%

Fruity

100%

90%

Vanilla

88%

Floral

50%

80%

Powdery

61%

65%

Sweet

73%

72%

Fresh

52%

64%

Amber

61%

Woody

46%

60%

Musky

50%

52%

White Floral

47%

Soft Spicy

50%

Citrus

48%

Fruity shared

100%

Vanilla

90%

Floral shared

88%

50%

Powdery shared

80%

61%

Sweet shared

65%

73%

Fresh shared

72%

52%

Amber

64%

Woody shared

61%

46%

Musky shared

60%

50%

White Floral shared

52%

47%

Soft Spicy

50%

Citrus

48%

Performance

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon Fleur de Murier

Moderate (4-6h)

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Moderate

Projection

Moderate

Intensity

Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

5th Avenue NYC Limited Editon

Seasons

Best For:

Spring Summer Autumn Winter

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Also Works:

Office Formal

Its soft sillage and inoffensive floral-fruity profile make it suitable for everyday wear, including the office. While many reviewers appreciate its versatility for day or night, its moderate longevity often requires reapplication for longer events.

Fleur de Murier

Seasons

Best For:

Spring Summer Autumn

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Also Works:

Office Sport

Its moderate projection and fresh, fruity opening make it suitable for casual wear or even the office, if sparingly applied. The unique woody-musky dry down adds a touch of intrigue for a laid-back date, but its unconventional character might be too bold for formal events.