This Maceration Station mystery is either a boozy, sweet powerhouse or a fleeting whiff of disappointment, depending on the bottle, the batch, and when you sniff it. If you get a good one, expect an Angel's Share clone that actually performs; otherwise, you'll be left wanting more.

This one's a divisive gourmand. Some rave about its photorealistic coffee and sweet rum-vanilla blend, while others find the coffee overpowering, bitter, and lacking balance. If you love smelling like a walking coffee shop, this could be your jam; if not, approach with caution.