Is Montagne Parfums Carlyle a dupe of Parfums de Marly Carlisle?
Where they differ
Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.
ScentArt
How it unfolds
Notes
- Carlisle
- Carlyle
- in both
Tap a note to light it in both. A+B means both have it
Which Should You Buy?
Dark, plush and very long-lasting, a statement for cold evenings. Spiced apple and saffron open it, rose and tonka warm the middle, and vanilla, patchouli and opoponax fall into a deep, sweet base.
A baked-apple, tonka and vanilla gourmand with warm spice. Carlyle follows Parfums de Marly Carlisle on paper and in feel, and reads a little sweeter and more tea-like.
Scent Profile
How They Wear
Mood
Notes
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Patchouli
16%
vs
9%
Vanilla
15%
vs
14%
Nutmeg
10%
vs
11%
Apple
10%
vs
13%
Saffron
9%
vs
10%
Tonka Bean
8%
vs
13%
Rose
8%
vs
8%
Davana
7%
vs
10%
Osmanthus
5%
vs
7%
Opoponax
7% share of the perfume
Patchouli
16%
vs
9%
Vanilla
15%
vs
14%
Opoponax
7% share of the perfume
Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.
Performance
Season and Occasion Fit
Seasons
Spiced apple, vanilla and patchouli make it a cold-weather scent: autumn and winter first, with a spring evening as the limit.
Occasions
Strong and long-lasting, it suits dates, dinners and formal events. In close quarters like an office it can overwhelm.
Seasons
Baked apple, tonka and vanilla are comfort notes made for autumn and winter. They cloy in warm weather.
Occasions
Good for evenings and dates. Too rich and sweet for a conservative workplace.
Similarity Breakdown
Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.
Shares 9 of its 10 notes, including Apple, Nutmeg, Saffron
Adds opoponax
Where to buy
Pick a size. The two cheapest offers, then the rest.
Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.
ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.