Black XS Eau de Parfum vs Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Black XS

Edp	Concentration	Edp
U	Gender	U
2018	Year	2008
££	Price Tier	££

Vanilla Extasy

ScentArt

A

Black XS

B

Vanilla Extasy

Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Black XS Eau de Parfum

This perfume is a divisive one. While some find it to be a unique, sexy, and addictive blend of dark fruits and cacao, others are let down by its perceived weakness and lack of longevity compared to its predecessor. It's a love-it-or-hate-it affair, often depending on skin chemistry and expectations.

Favourite

Our Verdict - Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Don't let the name fool you - Vanilla Extasy is a divisive Montale that’s more about a fruity-floral amber than a true gourmand vanilla. Many find it reminiscent of Flowerbomb, while others say it's more refined. Expect compliments, but don't expect a straight vanilla bomb.

Acquired

Scent Profile

Citrus	2%	0%
Floral	18%	25%
Fruity	17%	22%
Green	2%	1%
Sweet	35%	40%
Warm	15%	10%
Woody	15%	16%
Earthy	5%	5%
Animalic	0%	3%
Fresh	10%	5%

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

Black XS EdP

Vanilla Extasy EdP

Notes

Only in Black XS Eau de Parfum

Cranberry 45% Pink Pepper 33% Tamarind 22%

Only in Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Apricot 62% Apricot Blossom 38%

Only in Black XS Eau de Parfum

Cacao Pod 40% Rose 31% Violet 29%

Only in Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Vanilla 47% Ylang-Ylang 29% Jasmine 24%

Shared Notes

Sandalwood 32% vs 25%

Only in Black XS Eau de Parfum

Vanilla 38% Massoia 30%

Only in Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Benzoin 27% Resin 25% Mahogany 23%

Accords

Black XS Eau de Parfum Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

100%

Fruity

68%

79%

Vanilla

100%

84%

Woody

95%

92%

Cacao

90%

Warm Spicy

57%

Amber

86%

84%

Powdery

77%

Sweet

69%

75%

Rose

71%

Soft Spicy

62%

Violet Floral

Balsamic

62%

Floral

57%

Yellow Floral

56%

Fruity shared

100%

68%

Vanilla shared

79%

100%

Woody shared

84%

95%

Cacao

92%

Warm Spicy shared

90%

57%

Amber

86%

Powdery shared

84%

77%

Sweet shared

77%

69%

Rose

75%

Soft Spicy

71%

Violet Floral

62%

Balsamic

62%

Floral

57%

Yellow Floral

56%

Performance

Black XS Eau de Parfum Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Moderate (4-6h)

Longevity

Long (6-10h)

Moderate

Projection

Strong

Moderate

Intensity

Strong

Season and Occasion Fit

Black XS Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:

Autumn Winter

A cold-weather scent - best worn in winter and autumn.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Also Works:

Formal

Its intimate sillage and seductive, dark profile mean it's ideal for dates and evening events where you want to make a statement without overpowering. However, its perceived weakness by some users makes it less suitable for formal settings requiring strong projection, and it's certainly not a sport fragrance.

Vanilla Extasy Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:

Spring Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Also Works:

Office Formal

With its strong sillage and impressive longevity, especially for a Montale, this fragrance is best suited for dates and casual wear where its seductive nature can shine. It might be a bit much for a formal office setting due to its strength, but could work for an energetic casual day if applied lightly.