M £ Favourite

Why Not

Name: Why Not Eau de Parfum
Brand: Duppe Scents

Duppe Scents Why Not is an Eau de Parfum. Why Not opens with Bergamot, Ginger, and Apple, settles into a heart of Geranium and Sage, and dries down to a base of Cedar, Vetiver, and Tonka Bean. Duppe Scents's Why Not carries a Favourite verdict, a woody-led wear.

This one follows YSL Y's apple-ginger-bergamot opening closely and its sage-geranium heart is a fair match, though the smoky incense finish that gives the original its depth is largely absent.

What our verdicts mean →

Confident
Modern
Clean
Ambitious

Check price on

→ Check prices ↓

Inspired by

Y by Yves Saint Laurent

90%

Compare these two →

Our estimate of scent similarity, calculated from published notes. How we score it

See how they compare

Y the original Why Not inspired by

Scent Profile

Composition

Timeline

Showing: Overall Blend

Topas listed

Apple35%

Bergamot35%

Ginger29%

Heartas listed

Sage56%

Geranium44%

Baseas listed

Cedar38%

Tonka Bean31%

Vetiver31%

Top, heart and base are the brand's own listing, not a timing claim - the industry classifies a note by its character as much as by how fast it fades. Each curve here is modelled from that material's own volatility, so groups can overlap when a house lists long-lasting materials in its heart.

ScentArt

ScentArt Gallery What is ScentArt?

Performance & Mood

Performance

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Projection

Moderate

Intensity

Moderate

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

When To Wear

Best Seasons

Also Works:

Spring Summer Fall

A fresh aromatic fougere that works across most of the year, with its sharpest character in spring and autumn.

Best Occasions

Best For:

Office Casual

Also Works:

Date Formal

Clean and confident enough for the office, with enough warmth in the base for a casual evening too.

Ingredients and allergens

We don't have this fragrance's ingredient list yet.

About

This dupe opens with the same crisp apple, ginger and bergamot combination that makes YSL's Y Eau de Parfum an easy modern fougere, with a clean, energising lift. Sage and geranium carry the aromatic heart, matching the original's green, slightly herbal middle stage well. The base moves into cedarwood, tonka bean and vetiver for a warm, woody finish that's broadly in the same family as the real thing. Where it comes up short is the smoky incense note that reviewers point to as giving Y its extra character beyond the crowded blue-fresh category; that facet is thin here, leaving a more generic woody-fresh finish. Still, the apple-bergamot opening and aromatic heart are close enough to be genuinely recognisable, and it wears as a confident, easy everyday scent even if it doesn't quite reach the original's polish.

Similar

Compare & Pair

Compare Why Not Eau de Parfum

Pick any perfume to see the two side by side.

Layer

Wear two at once: the blends worth trying, how each one scores and where to spray See what layers well

Complement

Two people, two scents: what sits well beside it when you each wear your own See what pairs well

Where to buy

Prices for the United States ·

Import charges may apply

These shops are outside the United States. How import charges work

Duppe Scents 0.0 fl oz (0 ml) Delivers to the United States from the United Kingdom 0.0 fl oz (0 ml) $-/fl oz - $39.95 Buy → Delivers to the United States from the United Kingdom

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Why Not