Favourite

M £

Why Not

Name: Why Not Eau de Parfum
Brand: Duppe Scents
Availability: InStock

Duppe Scents Why Not is an Eau de Parfum. Why Not opens with Bergamot, Ginger, and Apple, settles into a heart of Geranium and Sage, and dries down to a base of Cedar, Vetiver, and Tonka Bean. Duppe Scents's Why Not carries a Favourite verdict, a aromatic-led wear.

This one follows YSL Y's apple-ginger-bergamot opening closely and its sage-geranium heart is a fair match, though the smoky incense finish that gives the original its depth is largely absent.

Check price on

→ Check prices ↓

Confident
Modern
Clean
Ambitious

Profile

Composition

Timeline

Showing: Overall Blend

Accords

Aromatic

70%

Woody

60%

Fresh Spicy

50%

Fougere

40%

ScentArt

Full Screen What is ScentArt?

Performance

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Projection

Moderate

Intensity

Moderate

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

When To Wear

Best Seasons

Also Works:

Spring Summer Fall

A fresh aromatic fougere that works across most of the year, with its sharpest character in spring and autumn.

Best Occasions

Best For:

Office Casual

Also Works:

Date Formal

Clean and confident enough for the office, with enough warmth in the base for a casual evening too.

Similar

Compare

Compare Why Not Eau de Parfum with...

Layer

Wear two at once. See what layers well with Why Not Eau de Parfum - the blends worth trying, and how each one scores.

Complement

Round out the rotation. See what complements Why Not Eau de Parfum - fragrances that pair with it, worn side by side.

Where to buy

Some links earn us a commission if you buy - it never affects your price or how we rank these

Wide selection Amazon UK Prime delivery often available Check price on

→

Duppe Scents £39.95 Buy

Check price on

→

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

About

This dupe opens with the same crisp apple, ginger and bergamot combination that makes YSL's Y Eau de Parfum an easy modern fougere, with a clean, energising lift. Sage and geranium carry the aromatic heart, matching the original's green, slightly herbal middle stage well. The base moves into cedarwood, tonka bean and vetiver for a warm, woody finish that's broadly in the same family as the real thing. Where it comes up short is the smoky incense note that reviewers point to as giving Y its extra character beyond the crowded blue-fresh category; that facet is thin here, leaving a more generic woody-fresh finish. Still, the apple-bergamot opening and aromatic heart are close enough to be genuinely recognisable, and it wears as a confident, easy everyday scent even if it doesn't quite reach the original's polish.