UK Perfume Dupes Compared: Algorithm vs Real Reviews

Twelve UK dupes scored on estimated scent similarity, then set against what the verdict on each page says. Where the score and the wearers agree, and where they part ways.

A row of assorted perfume bottles on a reflective surface with laboratory glassware and a balance scale in the background, under warm lighting

The UK dupes with the highest estimated scent similarity and a warm wearer verdict are Maison Alhambra Como Moiselle for Chanel Coco Mademoiselle, Zara Red Temptation for Baccarat Rouge 540 and Maison Alhambra Léonie for YSL Libre, all at 93%, with Lidl Suddenly Madame Glamour for Coco Mademoiselle close behind at 90%. This guide puts twelve dupes side by side, gives each one its score, then sets it against the verdict on its page, compiled from wearer reports, so you can see where the two agree and where they part ways.

How we know. Every figure here was read from our catalogue on 27 October 2026. Our estimated scent similarity scores every note on 34 facets, blends them into one shape per perfume and measures how far apart two shapes sit. It is an estimate from published notes, not a measured percentage and not a side-by-side smell test, and our methodology explains the scale: 90 and above is near-identical, 80 to 89 is clearly the same territory, and below 80 is a family resemblance. The wearer side is the verdict on each perfume page, compiled from wearer reports. Sources: our perfume verdicts, notes and scent profiles, the source recorded on each dupe pairing, and the stock our tracked shops report. Every score can be checked on the pair's compare page, which lists the notes the two share and the notes they do not. If a figure looks wrong, tell us and we will check it.

Dupes worth a look

Dupe Original Estimated scent similarity What the verdict says Where to buy
Maison Alhambra Como Moiselle Chanel Coco Mademoiselle 93% A ridiculously good dupe Where to buy
Zara Red Temptation Baccarat Rouge 540 93% A lush vanilla-amber bomb Where to buy
Maison Alhambra Léonie YSL Libre 93% A crowd-pleaser, a little synthetic to some Where to buy
Lidl Suddenly Madame Glamour Coco Mademoiselle 90% Punches above its weight, short on longevity Details
Maison Alhambra Tobacco Touch Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille 84% Cosy and room-filling, clove-heavy Where to buy
Dossier Ambery Saffron Baccarat Rouge 540 80% Strikingly close, plush and warm Where to buy
Armaf Club de Nuit Intense Man Creed Aventus 79% A citrus-smoky powerhouse Where to buy
Maison Alhambra Salvo Dior Sauvage Eau de Parfum 93% Not a perfect clone Where to buy
Maison Alhambra Black Origami Tom Ford Black Orchid 93% Divisive, not a safe blind buy Where to buy
M&S Discover Sweet Pistachio Kayali Yum Pistachio Gelato 33 Lower A joyful, nutty crowd-pleaser Where to buy
Perfume Parlour Card Red Baccarat Rouge 540 Lower An affordable, warm alternative Details
Milton-Lloyd No.9 Victor Creed Aventus Lower Ultra-budget, fruity and smoky Where to buy

What our data shows

These figures were read from our catalogue on 27 October 2026.

  • How many pairs. We hold 8,381 dupe pairings where both perfumes are published, and 1,839 of them have a published comparison page. Of the 8,381, 5,420 (65%) score 60 or more and 2,688 score 90 or more.
  • Who says it is a dupe. The dupe house itself names the original in 4,797 pairings, the fragrance community in 3,326, our pipeline detected 167, and 91 have no recorded source. Of the pairings the houses name, 71% score 60 or more. Of the community's, 57% do.
  • A high score is no guarantee of a warm verdict. About 23% of the verdicts on dupes that score 90 or more carry a caution, with words such as weak, synthetic, divisive or skip. It is the same share, about 23%, at 80 to 89 and at 60 to 79. The number tells you how alike two bottles read on paper, and the verdict tells you how they wear.
  • The originals' perfumers. Our pages credit Jacques Polge for Coco Mademoiselle, Francis Kurkdjian for Baccarat Rouge 540, Olivier Gillotin for Tobacco Vanille, Anne Flipo and Carlos Benaïm for Libre, François Demachy for Sauvage, David Apel and Pierre Negrin for Black Orchid, and Jean-Christophe Hérault and Erwin Creed for Aventus. The dupe houses list no perfumer for their bottles, so for those the verdict is the evidence.
  • Coverage we track. In October 2026, Club de Nuit Intense Man is stocked by 10 of the shops we track in the UK and 6 in the US, Léonie by 5 and 3, Salvo by 3 and 3, Milton-Lloyd No.9 Victor by 3 in the UK, and Dossier Ambery Saffron by 2 and 1. Como Moiselle has 2 in the UK. Tobacco Touch, Red Temptation and Black Origami each have 1 in the UK, and M&S Sweet Pistachio 1. Lidl Madame Glamour and Card Red are not in stock at any shop we track.

Where the score and the wearers agree

These are the safer buys. The score is 79% or higher, the verdict is warm and the caveats are about nuance, not about whether it works.

Como Moiselle for Coco Mademoiselle. Our score of 93% is the highest in the set, with every one of its 14 notes in the original. The verdict calls it a ridiculously good dupe and an essential blind buy for anyone who loves the Coco Mademoiselle character. Choose it if you want the citrus-patchouli-floral look of the Chanel. Skip it if you want the original's refinement.

Red Temptation for Baccarat Rouge 540. Also 93%, sharing 9 of its 10 notes with the original. The verdict calls it an affordable showstopper for lovers of decadent sweetness, and our profile rates it long lasting. The comparison page notes it is denser and more gourmand than the airy original. Choose it if you want a cosy amber-vanilla. Skip it if you want Baccarat Rouge 540's crystalline lightness.

Léonie for YSL Libre. 93%, with all ten of its notes in Libre, jasmine, lavender and vanilla among them. The verdict calls it a clear crowd-pleaser and a brilliant budget buy, with impressive longevity, although some find it too synthetic or grandmotherly. Choose it if you want Libre's white-floral-and-lavender look. Skip it if a synthetic edge bothers you.

Suddenly Madame Glamour for Coco Mademoiselle. 90%, with all 11 of its notes in the original. The verdict says it punches well above its weight for a cheapie and delights most wearers, while lacking the refined longevity of the Chanel. Choose it if you want an easy daily crowd-pleaser. Skip it if you want long wear.

Tobacco Touch for Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille. 84%, with every one of its seven notes in the original. The verdict calls it a room-filling autumn-winter stunner with remarkable power, but its clove-heavy opening and deep sweetness need a cool setting. Our profile rates it very long lasting. Choose it if you want a loud, sweet tobacco. Skip it if you want the Tom Ford's smoothness.

Ambery Saffron for Baccarat Rouge 540. 80%, named by the house itself as the original. The verdict calls it a plush, warm amber-woods with a spicy saffron twist, strikingly close to its inspiration, and the comparison page notes softer performance and less complexity. Choose it if you want a warmer take on Baccarat Rouge 540. Skip it if you want its metallic radiance.

Club de Nuit Intense Man for Creed Aventus. 79%, sharing 9 of its 12 notes with Aventus. The verdict calls it a citrus-smoky powerhouse that makes a statement, and the comparison page says it is sharper, louder and less nuanced than the Creed. Our profile rates it long lasting with strong projection. Choose it if you want to be noticed. Skip it if you want subtlety.

Where the score is high and the wearers are cautious

A high score does not settle it. These two share the original's notes almost entirely, and the verdicts still warn.

Salvo for Dior Sauvage Eau de Parfum. 93%, with all seven of its notes in the original. The verdict calls it a budget crowd-pleaser but not a perfect clone, and the comparison page describes a slightly sharper, more synthetic edge. Choose it if you want a clean, peppery ambroxan for everyday wear. Skip it if you want Sauvage's smoothness.

Black Origami for Black Orchid. 93%, sharing 19 of its 20 notes. The verdict calls it divisive: some see a near-perfect dupe, others decry its initial harshness and poor longevity, and it advises patience for maceration and says it is not a safe blind buy. Choose it if you can sample first. Skip it if you want a sure thing.

Where the score reads it lower than the wearers

These pairs sit well below the rest on estimated scent similarity, and the verdicts are still warm. Read the verdict next to the number.

M&S Discover Sweet Pistachio for Kayali Yum Pistachio Gelato 33. The score is the widest gap in this set: it shares only 5 of Kayali's 21 notes. The verdict calls it a joyful, nuttily sweet crowd-pleaser, and the comparison page calls it a close-dupe success story, prettier and more skin-close than the Kayali. Choose it if you want the pistachio-gourmand idea. Skip it if you want Kayali's full trail.

Card Red for Baccarat Rouge 540. The verdict calls it an affordable, well-crafted alternative with a warm, woody, slightly spicy scent, and the comparison page says it trades the original's crystalline opulence for a warmer profile with less projection. Choose it if you want a warm saffron-wood. Skip it if you want Baccarat Rouge 540's radiance.

No.9 Victor for Aventus. The verdict describes a vibrant fruity-citrus burst over smoky woods and good value, though not the richest or most natural. Choose it if you want an Aventus-style idea with fewer notes. Skip it if you want Aventus's depth.

Smells alike, but not a dupe

Some pairs score high because they really do smell related, not because one copies the other. Sauvage Eau de Toilette and Bleu de Chanel Eau de Parfum are at 80%, sharing pink pepper, bergamot and cedar. Jacques Polge is credited on Bleu de Chanel and François Demachy on Sauvage. The comparison page calls Bleu the more refined, versatile choice and Sauvage the louder, more attention-grabbing one. If you like one and want something in the same lane, the score is telling you the truth.

What the gap actually tells you

  • When the score and the verdict both land high, buy with confidence. Two independent readings agreeing is a stronger signal than either alone.
  • When the score is high and the verdict warns, sample first. The notes match, and the performance or synthetic edge is what differs.
  • When the score reads lower and the verdict is warm, the dupe is probably a simpler version of a richer original. Read the verdict.
  • A high score means "smells alike", which is not always "is a dupe of".
  • What the score cannot smell is execution. Longevity, projection and a synthetic edge are not in the notes.

Dupe questions

What are the M&S fragrance dupes?

The strongest M&S pairings in our data are Autograph Black Amber for Chanel Coco Noir at 77%, Island Sunset for Rabanne Olympea at 76%, Butterfly for Marc Jacobs Daisy at 74%, Discover Soft Oud for Mancera Roses Vanille at 73% and Discover Soft Iris for Coco Mademoiselle at 72%. Their pages carry the verdicts.

Which company has the best perfume dupes?

We do not rank companies. By count, Perfume Parlour has the most pairings that score 90 or more (1,074 of 2,476), then Eden Perfumes (182 of 447), Fragrance World (147 of 286) and Maison Alhambra (120 of 309). A count of high scores says how closely a house follows its targets on paper, not how its bottles wear, so read the verdict on each page.

What is Aldi No. 39 a dupe of?

Aldi's Lacura Hotel Collection No.39 Poppy & Barley is mapped to Jo Malone London Poppy & Barley Cologne, at 89% estimated scent similarity. Its verdict calls it an impressive, fruity-floral alternative.

Can you give me a list of dupes?

The table above is a start. Every dupe pair we have scored, each with its estimated scent similarity, is in the UK Perfume Dupe Index.

How we chose

The picks are drawn from the verdicts on our perfume pages, which are compiled from wearer reports, with our scent profiles, the shop coverage we track and the estimated scent similarity above. We read that data in October 2026. For how we build and check it, see our methodology. Some buy links may earn us a commission, and our scores and verdicts do not depend on it.

More from the Magazine

Dupes 11 min read

Best Santal 33 Dupes Compared (2026)

Ten mapped dupes and two close alternatives for Le Labo Santal 33, compared with the original by notes, estimated scent similarity and verdicts.