Is Chatler X by Michael Shard a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y?
Where they differ
Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.
ScentArt
How it unfolds
Notes
- Y
- X by Michael Shard
- in both
Tap a note to light it in both. A+B means both have it
Which Should You Buy?
Green apple and bergamot bring a crisp, vivid opening, followed by aromatic herbs and a dry, warm base of woods, tonka and frankincense.
Sparkling aldehydes, lemon and mint lead into apple, pineapple and sage, then settle on cedar, vetiver and incense for a crisp, woody finish.
Scent Profile
How They Wear
Mood
Notes
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Apple
25%
vs
7%
Bergamot
17%
vs
6%
Ginger
11%
vs
6%
Cedar
5%
vs
6%
Vetiver
4%
vs
5%
Sage
4%
vs
6%
Geranium
1%
vs
5%
Amberwood
12% share of the perfume
Tonka Bean
8% share of the perfume
Frankincense
4% share of the perfume
Juniper
3% share of the perfume
Lavender
2% share of the perfume
Patchouli
1% share of the perfume
Amber
7% share of the perfume
Aldehydes
7% share of the perfume
Musk
7% share of the perfume
Violet Leaf
7% share of the perfume
Canadian Fir Balsam
6% share of the perfume
Pineapple
6% share of the perfume
Mint
6% share of the perfume
Lemon
5% share of the perfume
Incense
5% share of the perfume
Bergamot
17%
vs
6%
Ginger
11%
vs
6%
Aldehydes
7% share of the perfume
Mint
6% share of the perfume
Lemon
5% share of the perfume
Sage
4%
vs
6%
Geranium
1%
vs
5%
Lavender
2% share of the perfume
Apple
7% share of the perfume
Violet Leaf
7% share of the perfume
Pineapple
6% share of the perfume
Cedar
5%
vs
6%
Vetiver
4%
vs
5%
Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.
Performance
Season and Occasion Fit
Seasons
Crisp apple, bergamot and ginger sit beside the fuller warmth of vanilla, tonka bean, frankincense and woods.
Occasions
Sage, lavender and geranium add an aromatic centre to the green fruit and dry woods.
Seasons
Lemon, mint, ginger and aldehydes keep it bright and crisp, which favours spring and summer, while cedar, balsam fir and incense add enough depth for autumn.
Occasions
Crisp aldehydes, lemon and mint read tidy and bright, so it works at work and in casual settings, while cedar and incense give it some formal weight.
Similarity Breakdown
Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.
Shares 7 of its 13 notes, including Bergamot, Cedar, Vetiver
Adds amberwood and frankincense, drops aldehydes and amber
Where to buy
Pick a size. The two cheapest offers, then the rest.
Y EDP
Check price onRefills and gift sets (5)
Refills (3)
Gift sets (2)
X by Michael Shard EDT
Check price onNo other shop we track that delivers to you has it in stock.
Other (5)
Refills (3)
Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.
ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.