Is Yom & Layl Mina a dupe of Creed Carmina?

Carmina EDP

Creed   Original Statement

Mina Oil

Yom & Layl   Inspired Favourite
Share
Card A shareable image comparing these two fragrances - verdicts, profiles and what they share. Save or copy it to post anywhere.
Carmina Eau de Parfum bottle Carmina EDP
EDP Concentration Oil
F Gender F
2023 Year -
$$$$$ Price Tier $
Mina Perfume Oil bottle Mina Oil
$307.49+ tax from
1.0 fl oz (30 ml) at eCosmetics
Best value $125.78/fl oz (2.5 fl oz (75 ml))
Buy Carmina Check price on →
$37.49+ tax from
1.0 fl oz (30 ml) at Yom & Layl
Best value $18.85/fl oz (3.4 fl oz (100 ml))
Buy Mina Check price on →

Where they differ

Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.

ScentArt

Carmina Eau de Parfum ScentArt View Liquid → Carmina EDP
Mina Perfume Oil ScentArt View Liquid → Mina Oil

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Carmina EDP
Carmina is a polarising beast. For every lover of its dark, jammy rose and cherry, there’s a hater smelling cough syrup and ambroxan. You'll either get Morticia Addams or an allergic reaction, apparently.
Statement
Our Verdict - Mina Oil
Black cherry and saffron over May rose, peony and violet, resting on musk, myrrh and frankincense. Mina follows Creed Carmina: a plush rose and cherry floral wrapped in a little resin smoke.
Favourite

Scent Profile

How they compare
Carmina EDP A Mina Oil B
Where they part company by gap size

How They Wear

Showing: Overall Blend

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Carmina EDP
Mina Oil

Notes

Shared Notes
Black Cherry Black Cherry 12% vs 12%
Saffron Saffron 10% vs 8%
Ambroxan Ambroxan 10% vs 8%
Musk Musk 9% vs 10%
Peony Peony 9% vs 8%
Cashmeran Cashmeran 8% vs 6%
Pink Pepper Pink Pepper 8% vs 7%
Violet Violet 7% vs 6%
Myrrh Myrrh 4% vs 8%
Shared Notes
Black Cherry Black Cherry 12% vs 12%
Saffron Saffron 10% vs 8%
Pink Pepper Pink Pepper 8% vs 7%
Shared Notes
Peony Peony 9% vs 8%
Cashmeran Cashmeran 8% vs 6%
Violet Violet 7% vs 6%
Shared Notes
Ambroxan Ambroxan 10% vs 8%
Musk Musk 9% vs 10%
Myrrh Myrrh 4% vs 8%

Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.

Performance

Carmina Mina
Moderate (4-6h)
Longevity
Moderate (4-6h)
Moderate
Projection
Moderate
Strong
Intensity
Strong

Season and Occasion Fit

Carmina

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Autumn Winter
Also Works:
Summer

A year-round scent - easy to wear in any season.

Occasions

Best For:
Formal
Also Works:
Date Casual

Its strong, often long-lasting sillage makes it too much for an office, as some find it headache-inducing. However, its 'dark feminine' and 'seductive' qualities make it perfect for date nights and formal evening wear, while being too sophisticated for casual daily use.

Mina

Seasons

Best For:
Autumn Winter
Also Works:
Spring

Dark cherry, rose and resins are rich and warm, which suits autumn and winter. They feel heavy in summer heat.

Occasions

Also Works:
Date Casual Formal

Rich and romantic, so it is best for dates, dinners and dressed-up evenings. It is a little intense for a quiet office.

Similarity Breakdown

Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.

Overall scent match
91%
Key Similarities

Shares 10 of its 11 notes, including Black Cherry, Saffron, Pink Pepper

Key Differences

Adds grasse rose absolute, drops rose

Where to buy

Carmina EDP
Mina Oil

Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS