If you're after something pleasant and familiar, Jimmy Choo Man Extreme does the job with its crowd-pleasing, Sauvage-esque vibe. However, don't expect innovation; it’s a solid, safe bet that smells good but won’t turn heads for originality. A fine first designer, but redundant if you own similar scents.

This one's a bit of a tease. Beautiful, fresh, and uniquely herbal up top, but it largely fizzles out, leaving many wanting more depth and longevity. It's a genuine love-it-or-leave-it that struggles with its own subtlety.