Is Monac Attar Why a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y?
Where they differ
Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.
ScentArt
How it unfolds
Notes
- Y
- Why
- in both
Tap a note to light it in both. A+B means both have it
Which Should You Buy?
Y Eau de Parfum is the benchmark of modern aromatic masculinity - vibrant, crisp, and versatile with just enough woody richness to leave a lasting impression without ever shouting.
Why opens with bright bergamot, lemon and ginger, then cools into apple, sage and violet leaf. Ambergris, cedar and fir give the dry-down a clean, woody finish.
Scent Profile
How They Wear
Mood
Notes
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Apple
25%
vs
7%
Bergamot
17%
vs
7%
Ginger
11%
vs
7%
Cedar
5%
vs
6%
Vetiver
4%
vs
5%
Sage
4%
vs
7%
Geranium
1%
vs
6%
Amberwood
12% share of the perfume
Tonka Bean
8% share of the perfume
Frankincense
4% share of the perfume
Juniper
3% share of the perfume
Lavender
2% share of the perfume
Patchouli
1% share of the perfume
Lemon
7% share of the perfume
Ambergris
7% share of the perfume
Canadian Fir Balsam
6% share of the perfume
Incense
6% share of the perfume
Pineapple
6% share of the perfume
Musk
6% share of the perfume
Violet Leaf
6% share of the perfume
Aldehydes
6% share of the perfume
Mint
5% share of the perfume
Cedar
5%
vs
6%
Vetiver
4%
vs
5%
Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.
Performance
Season and Occasion Fit
Seasons
Its vibrant citrus, apple, and aromatic top notes make Y Eau de Parfum ideal for spring and fall when a fresh yet substantial signature is desirable. Summer works due to the freshness, but the denser woody and spicy base can feel too much in high heat, while winter mutes the brightness.
Occasions
Versatile projection and clean, modern profile make this safe but distinctive for office and casual settings. The aromatic freshness can suit dates, but it lacks the elegance for formal wear and the minimalism for sport.
Seasons
Citrus, mint, ginger and sage give Why a fresh, aromatic character that suits spring and summer. Cedar, ambergris and balsam fir bring enough warmth for autumn, while the brisk opening feels less at home in deep winter.
Occasions
The crisp citrus and restrained woods fit office hours and casual daytime plans. It can carry into an informal evening, though its light, fresh character is less suited to formal events or exercise.
Similarity Breakdown
Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.
Shares 7 of its 13 notes, including Cedar, Vetiver, Geranium
Adds amberwood and frankincense, drops aldehydes and ambergris
Where to buy
Pick a size. The two cheapest offers, then the rest.
Y EDP
Check price onRefills and gift sets (4)
Refills (2)
Gift sets (2)
Other (4)
Refills (2)
Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.
ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.