4160 Tuesdays 2018 EDP

U ££ Statement

Creamy Vanilla Crumble

by Sarah McCartney

Share
Card A shareable image of this fragrance - its verdict, notes and profile. Save or copy it to post anywhere.

4160 Tuesdays Creamy Vanilla Crumble is an Eau de Parfum launched in 2018, created by Sarah McCartney. Creamy Vanilla Crumble opens with Cream, settles into a heart of Vanilla and Malt, and dries down to a base of Musk, Tobacco, and Hay. 4160 Tuesdays's Creamy Vanilla Crumble carries a Statement verdict, a sweet-led wear.

This one's a proper divisive scent. Think creamy, sweet vanilla custard with an earthy, smoky twist. Some rave about its unique complexity, while others recoil from what they perceive as a waxy, burnt, or even 'cat pee' aroma. Definitely not a safe blind buy, get your nose on it first.
What our verdicts mean →
  • Cozy
  • Warm
  • Unique
  • Complex
  • Relaxed
£80.00 at 4160 Tuesdays 30ml Check prices ↓
Creamy Vanilla Crumble Eau de Parfum bottle

Profile

Composition

Timeline

Showing: Overall Blend

Top, heart and base are the brand's own listing, not a timing claim - the industry classifies a note by its character as much as by how fast it fades. Each curve here is modelled from that material's own volatility, so groups can overlap when a house lists long-lasting materials in its heart.

Notes

Top

CreamCream

Heart

VanillaVanillaMaltMalt

Base

HayHayTobaccoTobaccoMuskMusk

ScentArt

ScentArt Explorer What is ScentArt?

Performance

Longevity
Moderate (4-6h)
Projection
Moderate
Intensity
Moderate

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding

When To Wear

Best Seasons

Best For:
Fall Winter
Also Works:
Spring

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Best Occasions

Best For:
Date Casual

With its gourmand, creamy nature and a tendency towards strong projection and lasting power, this is better suited for casual or date settings where its unique facets can be appreciated. It's too distinctive and potentially polarising for formal events or the office, and certainly not for sport.

Declarable allergens

We derive these from the materials behind this fragrance's notes, not from the bottle. Each one is likely, not confirmed. The list is partial - the box can name others.

Declarable under EU Annex III

  • Synthetic musk Hexamethylindanopyran from Musk
  • Vanillin from Vanilla

The large name is the everyday one. The small name is the INCI form on the box, so you can compare the two. Reactions differ between people. A patch-test panel is not a ranking of risk. How we derive this

Similar

Compare

Layer

Wear two at once. See what layers well with Creamy Vanilla Crumble Eau de Parfum - the blends worth trying, and how each one scores.

Complement

Round out the rotation. See what complements Creamy Vanilla Crumble Eau de Parfum - fragrances that pair with it, worn side by side.

Where to buy

Some links earn us a commission if you buy - it never affects your price or how we rank these

Prices checked 9 August 2026 · 4 offers from 1 retailer

Cheapest Sample £50.00 4160 Tuesdays - 15ml Buy Cheapest Bottle £80.00 4160 Tuesdays - 30ml Buy Best Value £190.00 4160 Tuesdays - 100ml - £1.90/ml Buy

Cheapest Bottle and Best Value cover full bottles from 30ml up; samples and decants get their own pick. All three skip marketplace listings, refills and implausible outliers - every offer still shows in full below. How we rank offers

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

About

Opens with a rich, lactonic hit of vanilla and cream, evoking a warm, inviting custard. As it settles, malt adds a bready, slightly boozy depth, paving the way for a distinctly earthy and smoky dry-down. Hay delivers a dry, rustic greenness, while a subtle tobacco note adds an intriguing, almost burnt edge, all grounded by a soft musk.

Drawn from community reviews and editor-reviewed before publishing on . See our methodology and disclosure policy.