A sugary, fizzy cherry burst that captured hearts then dashed hopes. Everyone's kicking themselves for not stocking up this discontinued gem. It's not complex, but what it does it does well, though some found it frustratingly fleeting or too artificial.

317 nails Escada Cherry In The Air's sweet cherry-marshmallow signature at the top, though it settles into a much thinner sandalwood-suede base than the original.