This Kilian offering is utterly divisive; for some, it's a fizzy, playful Coke dream, for others, a fleeting novelty that quickly descends into generic men's cologne. Love it or hate it, just don't expect the cola to last.

Rogue chases Kilian's photorealistic cola opening with cinnamon, apple and nutmeg behind it, and the fizzy cola-lime idea genuinely lands, but the woody base is thinner and the whole thing fades far faster than Kilian's polished, expensive original.