Card A shareable image comparing these two fragrances - verdicts, profiles and what they share. Save or copy it to post anywhere.
Lemon Pie Eau de Parfum bottle Lemon Pie EDP
EDP Concentration EDP
U Gender U
2025 Year 2020
££ Price Tier ££
Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar Eau de Parfum bottle Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar EDP

ScentArt

View Liquid → Lemon Pie EDP
View Liquid → Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar EDP

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Lemon Pie EDP
If you came for lemon pie, you're getting lemon pie. This is a hyper-realistic gourmand that smells exactly as advertised, though some find it a bit too true to life, leaning into 'burnt crust' or 'butter' territory. Longevity is the main gripe, so be prepared to reapply.
Statement
Our Verdict - Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar EDP
An inviting blend of candied sweetness and warm vanilla makes Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar a perfect choice for those looking to indulge their sweet tooth without being overpowering.
Favourite

Scent Profile

How They Wear

Showing: Overall Blend

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Lemon Pie EDP
Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar EDP

Notes

Shared Notes
Bergamot 21% vs 71%
Only in Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar
Pepper 29%
Shared Notes
Vanilla 26% vs 50%
Tonka Bean 17% vs 27%
Only in Lemon Pie
Biscuit 34% Cream 22%
Only in Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar
Almond 22%

Accords

Lemon Pie Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar
100%
Sweet
90%
Gourmand
95%
67%
Vanilla
85%
54%
Citrus
Balsamic
50%
49%
Powdery
42%
Lactonic
Sweet shared
100%
90%
95%
Vanilla shared
67%
85%
54%
50%
49%
42%

Performance

Lemon Pie Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar
Short (2-4h)
Longevity
Long (6-10h)
Moderate
Projection
Moderate
Light
Intensity
Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Lemon Pie

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Summer
Also Works:
Winter

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:
Casual
Also Works:
Date

Its sweet gourmand profile and limited longevity make it less suitable for formal or office settings where professionalism and subtlety are key. It shines in casual situations and is a surprisingly fun choice for a date, IF you like to smell edible.

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Autumn
Also Works:
Winter

The sweet vanilla and gourmand notes make it fitting for cooler weather, such as spring and fall. It might be slightly too heavy for hot summer days.

Occasions

Best For:
Date Casual
Also Works:
Office Formal

This fragrance is suitable for daily use and casual dates with its sweet and inviting vanilla presence. Its moderate projection makes it appropriate for office wear but possibly too gourmand for formal occasions.

Similarity Breakdown

How alike these two fragrances smell, scored from their full scent profiles.

Overall scent match
84%
Key Similarities

Both lean sweet, vanilla

Key Differences

Subtle differences in overall composition

Where to buy

Lemon Pie EDP
Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar EDP
also worth checking

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS