Tom Ford's Rose de Chine is a divisive floral, offering a unique, often intense, take on rose. Some find it a refined, elegant oriental, while others are overwhelmed by a loud, even chemical peony-rose blend. You'll either love its smoky, spicy depth or dismiss it as an old-fashioned 'rich aunty' scent.

Star Lady captures the tart, jammy rose-and-amber heart of Stella by Stella McCartney. The ripe rose and clean amber base come through nicely, though it wears softer and closer to the skin than the polished original.