Rose Noir Eau de Parfum bottle Rose Noir
Edp Concentration Edp
U Gender U
2008 Year 1965
££££ Price Tier ££
Melograno Eau de Parfum bottle Melograno

ScentArt

A
Rose Noir
B
Melograno
Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Rose Noir Eau de Parfum
Rose Noir is a divisive one. There's a brilliant, moody rose and moss core for some, while for others, it's a sour, fleeting mess. Not a safe blind buy, so sample before committing - your chemistry may vary wildly.
Statement
Our Verdict - Melograno Eau de Parfum
This one's a proper marmite fragrance - you'll either love its intensely soapy, classic chypre character or find it utterly archaic. Don't go in expecting sweet pomegranate; this is an aldehydic, oakmoss-heavy statement that commands attention. Distinctly old-world, polarising, but undeniably grand.
Statement

Scent Profile

Citrus Floral Fruity Green Sweet Warm Woody Earthy Animalic Fresh
Citrus 9% 19%
Floral 30% 21%
Fruity 12% 11%
Green 8% 5%
Sweet 18% 16%
Warm 9% 13%
Woody 7% 8%
Earthy 16% 19%
Animalic 9% 8%
Fresh 17% 11%

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Rose Noir EdP
Melograno EdP

Notes

Shared Notes
Rose 32% vs 29%
Shared Notes
Oakmoss 30% vs 35%
Musk 24% vs 19%
Labdanum 24% vs 23%
Patchouli 19% vs 21%

Accords

Rose Noir Eau de Parfum Melograno Eau de Parfum
100%
Rose
58%
Woody
100%
81%
Mossy
86%
77%
Floral
69%
Earthy
77%
69%
Musky
57%
63%
Citrus
64%
57%
Amber
55%
Patchouli
51%
46%
Powdery
100%
Woody shared
58%
100%
Mossy shared
81%
86%
77%
Earthy shared
69%
77%
Musky shared
69%
57%
Citrus shared
63%
64%
Amber shared
57%
55%
51%
46%

Performance

Rose Noir Eau de Parfum Melograno Eau de Parfum
Moderate (4-6h)
Longevity
Moderate (4-6h)
Moderate
Projection
Moderate
Moderate
Intensity
Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Rose Noir Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Autumn
Also Works:
Summer Winter

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:
Date Formal
Also Works:
Casual

Its bold, sensual character, along with reports of decent sillage and longevity from some wearers, makes it an unsuitable choice for the office. However, its sophisticated and mysterious aura is perfectly suited for date nights and special evening events.

Melograno Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Autumn Winter
Also Works:
Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:
Date Formal
Also Works:
Casual

Its potent, classic profile and strong performance make it a bit much for the office or sport, leaning more towards formal events or sophisticated dates. While some find it clean enough for casual wear, its commanding presence suits more deliberate occasions.

Similarity Breakdown

Overall
86%
Olfactory
95%
Notes
89%
Accord
66%
Key Similarities

Both share Woody, Mossy, Earthy accords and Rose, Labdanum notes

Key Differences

Subtle differences in overall composition

Where to buy

Rose Noir Eau de Parfum
Melograno Eau de Parfum
also worth checking

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS