Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum vs Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Black XS (2018)

Edp	Concentration	Edp
U	Gender	U
2018	Year	2023
££	Price Tier	£

Amber Is Great

ScentArt

A

Black XS (2018)

B

Amber Is Great

Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum

This updated Black XS is a polarising beast. Some rave about its playful sweetness and mass-appealing charm, while others lament its weakened performance and what they see as a diluted version of the original. Expect compliments, but don't expect it to last.

Statement

Our Verdict - Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

This one is a divisive amber bomb, a 'love it or hate it' fragrance that punches above its price point. It's often compared to Erba Pura but with its own ambery, woody twist. Expect a potentially harsh opening for some, but a seductive dry down for those who stick with it.

Favourite

Scent Profile

Citrus	18%	18%
Floral	3%	0%
Fruity	1%	3%
Green	10%	7%
Sweet	20%	21%
Warm	19%	21%
Woody	17%	13%
Earthy	15%	18%
Animalic	6%	15%
Fresh	16%	14%

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

Black XS (2018) EdP

Amber Is Great EdP

Notes

Shared Notes

Citrus 32% vs 22%

Only in Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum

Lemon 30% Sage 20% Marigold 18%

Only in Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Cotton Candy 35% Woody 22% Saffron 20%

Only in Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum

Praline 35% Cinnamon 24% Tolu Balsam 21% Cardamom 20%

Only in Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Amber 37% Orange 24% Herbal 20% Lemon 18%

Shared Notes

Ambergris 25% vs 42%

Only in Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum

Patchouli 31% Ebony 23% Rosewood 20%

Only in Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Spicy 30% Oakmoss 28%

Accords

Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

100%

Citrus

78%

73%

Amber

100%

90%

Warm Spicy

48%

85%

Sweet

73%

71%

Aromatic

69%

Woody

49%

58%

Balsamic

55%

Fresh

55%

Patchouli

Animalic

55%

51%

Cinnamon

Citrus shared

100%

78%

Amber shared

73%

100%

Warm Spicy shared

90%

48%

Sweet shared

85%

73%

Aromatic

71%

Woody shared

69%

49%

Balsamic

58%

Fresh

55%

Patchouli

55%

Animalic

55%

Cinnamon

51%

Performance

Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Moderate (4-6h)

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Moderate

Projection

Moderate

Intensity

Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Black XS (2018) Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:

Spring Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Its sweet, playful nature and limited longevity make it less suitable for formal or office settings. It excels in casual and date scenarios where its charming, approachable scent can be appreciated up close, especially for younger wearers.

Amber Is Great Eau de Parfum

Seasons

Best For:

Spring Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Formal

Also Works:

Casual

Given its strong performance and rich, sweet, and amber-heavy profile, this perfume leans more towards evening and social events. It's too potent for an office setting but perfect for making a statement on a date or at a formal gathering.