Is ALT. Fragrances Melodia a dupe of Creed Carmina?
Where they differ
Biggest gaps first. The bolder side leads.
ScentArt
How it unfolds
Notes
- Carmina
- Melodia
- in both
Tap a note to light it in both. A+B means both have it
Which Should You Buy?
Dark black cherry and saffron give Carmina a spiced, fruity opening. Rose, peony and violet soften the heart, while musk, cashmeran, ambroxan and resins add depth.
Melodia starts with nutmeg’s dry warmth, sharpened by saffron and allspice. Rose and tuberose take over, with iris adding a powdery edge; amber, musk and vanilla bring the floral spice to a smooth close.
Scent Profile
How They Wear
Mood
Notes
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Saffron
10%
vs
11%
Musk
9%
vs
11%
Grasse Rose Absolute
13% share of the perfume
Black Cherry
13% share of the perfume
Ambroxan
11% share of the perfume
Peony
9% share of the perfume
Cashmeran
8% share of the perfume
Pink Pepper
8% share of the perfume
Violet
7% share of the perfume
Myrrh
5% share of the perfume
Frankincense
5% share of the perfume
Musk
9%
vs
11%
Note weights are our estimate from each note's place in the pyramid, not the share of the formula. Brands do not publish formulations.
Performance
Season and Occasion Fit
Seasons
Cherry, rose and saffron align most with spring and autumn, while musk and resins keep winter close. Summer is the more moderate seasonal fit.
Occasions
Formal is the strongest match, with dates and casual settings next. The rich fruit and resin combination is less aligned with office or sport.
Seasons
Saffron, nutmeg and allspice carry through to an amber-vanilla base. Rose and tuberose lighten the middle, but the warmth and smooth sweetness are stronger than the floral lift.
Occasions
A plush rose and tuberose heart sits over warm spice, amber and vanilla. The floral centre feels composed, while the base adds depth and softness.
Similarity Breakdown
Our estimate of how alike these two fragrances smell, calculated from their published notes. It is a position on our scale, not a measured percentage of shared smell.
Shares 2 of its 11 notes, including Musk, Saffron
Adds ambroxan and black cherry, drops allspice and amber
Where to buy
Pick a size. The two cheapest offers, then the rest.
Prices before sales tax, which the shop adds at checkout.
ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.