A creamy, comforting gourmand that's sadly discontinued, Jo Malone's Honey & Crocus is either pure marzipan heaven or play-doh hell. If you're after a snuggly, sweet almond-milk fantasy that avoids being sickly, this could be your elusive unicorn.

Tuscany Man copies Roberto Cavalli Uomo - the signature saffron-and-honey sweetness over a warm tonka-cedar base. The dupe nails the cosy spiced-sweet idea but renders it flatter and lighter, fading well short of the original's 8-hour staying power.