Card A shareable image comparing these two fragrances - verdicts, profiles and what they share. Save or copy it to post anywhere.
Black XS Eau de Toilette bottle Black XS EDT
EDT Concentration EDP
M Gender M
2005 Year -
££ Price Tier £
Noire Extra Eau de Parfum bottle Noire Extra EDP

ScentArt

View Liquid → Black XS EDT
View Liquid → Noire Extra EDP

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Black XS EDT
A legendary noughties fragrance, Black XS is a sweet, dark, and playful scent that's loved by many for its unique 'strawberry milkshake' vibe. Ignore the whiners, this one's a classic - but be warned, performance issues with newer batches mean you should hunt down a vintage if you can.
Statement
Our Verdict - Noire Extra EDP
Perfume Parlour's affordable interpretation of Black XS - a citrus fragrance led by Lemon, Sage, with aromatic depth. It captures the gist of the original at a fraction of the cost, rendering a touch simpler and quieter.
Favourite

Scent Profile

How They Wear

Showing: Overall Blend

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Black XS EDT
Noire Extra EDP

Notes

Shared Notes
Lemon 65% vs 53%
Sage 34% vs 46%
Shared Notes
Praline 36% vs 46%
Cinnamon 25% vs 53%

Accords

Black XS Noire Extra
100%
Sweet
54%
100%
Warm Spicy
66%
82%
Citrus
90%
70%
Aromatic
78%
73%
Amber
42%
66%
Woody
63%
Balsamic
61%
Cinnamon
56%
Patchouli
52%
Lactonic
Sweet shared
100%
54%
Warm Spicy shared
100%
66%
Citrus shared
82%
90%
Aromatic shared
70%
78%
Amber shared
73%
42%
66%
63%
61%
56%
52%

Performance

Black XS Noire Extra
Moderate (4-6h)
Longevity
Short (2-4h)
Moderate
Projection
Intimate
Moderate
Intensity
Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Black XS

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Autumn Winter
Also Works:
Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:
Date Casual

Black XS is a sweet, bold fragrance that's best suited for casual wear, dates, and nights out. Its moderate to strong sillage and sweet accords might be a bit much for a formal office setting, but it's a solid choice for social occasions.

Noire Extra

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Summer

Best in spring and summer - the citrus, aromatic profile suits those conditions, while extremes of heat or cold flatten the dupe's lighter composition.

Occasions

Best For:
Date Casual
Also Works:
Office Sport

Keep it for casual and daily - the citrus accord gives presence while the gentle projection keeps it crowd-friendly.

Similarity Breakdown

How alike these two fragrances smell, scored from their full scent profiles.

Overall scent match
47%
Key Similarities

Both lean sweet, warm spicy, citrus

Key Differences

Subtle differences in overall composition

Where to buy

Black XS EDT
Noire Extra EDP
also worth checking

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS