Drakkar Noir is a bona fide icon, a powerhouse of classic masculinity that's aged shockingly well. Today's iteration might be softer than its 80s beast mode, but it still delivers that sharp, clean barbershop swagger. It's a crowd-pleasing, dirt-cheap gem, despite performance grumbles.

Agua Brava is a divisive classic: some find it a timeless, masculine masterpiece with an aromatic, woody soul, while others dismiss it as a fleeting scent more akin to an old-school aftershave or even insect repellent. Its low price makes it tempting, but don't expect powerhouse performance.