I for Women Woody Floral With Vintage Rose Eau de Parfum vs Black XS Potion for Her Eau de Toilette
I for Women Woody Floral With Vintage Rose EDP
| EDP | Concentration | EDT |
| F | Gender | F |
| 2017 | Year | 2014 |
| £££££ | Price Tier | ££ |
Black XS Potion for Her EDT
ScentArt
Which Should You Buy?
This one's a divisive delight - some find it an arrogant masterpiece, others a perfectly pitched, fruity rose. Expect a bold, high-quality scent that won't go unnoticed. It’s definitely not a safe blind buy for everyone, but those who love it, really love it.
This flanker is a divisive one. Fans adore its dark, sweet, and unique character, equating it to a magical potion. Critics find it underwhelming, generic, or too similar to the original, lacking the promised depth.
Scent Profile
How They Wear
Mood
Notes
Top Notes
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Accords
Performance
Season and Occasion Fit
Seasons
Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.
Occasions
With strong projection and impressive longevity, this fragrance is best for occasions where you want to make a statement. Its luxurious and sparkling rose-amber profile makes it ideal for dates and formal events, while its boldness might be too much for a quiet office or a casual daytime outing.
Seasons
A cold-weather scent - best worn in autumn and spring.
Occasions
Its strong projection and dark, sensual character make it less suitable for office wear. This scent truly shines on dates or special occasions where its unique, bold presence can be fully appreciated, though some find it versatile enough for daily casual wear in colder weather.
Similarity Breakdown
How alike these two fragrances smell, scored from their full scent profiles.
Both lean rose, amber, citrus
Adds grapefruit and hellabore flower, drops cedar and mandarin
Where to buy
ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.