Stetson Eau de Parfum vs Manhattan Eau de Parfum

Stetson

Edp	Concentration	Edp
U	Gender	U
1981	Year	2022
£	Price Tier	£££££

Manhattan

ScentArt

A

Stetson

B

Manhattan

Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Stetson

Stetson is an absolute icon, and one that divides opinion squarely down the middle. Some call it an outdated 'old man' scent, while others say it's a timeless, cosy classic. If you're after a budget-friendly, sweet-powdery aromatic, this is your huckleberry. Just prepare for the 'old man' comments - or embrace them.

Statement

Our Verdict - Manhattan

Roja Manhattan is a divisive blend, loved for its sophisticated tobacco-vanilla warmth but criticised for its weak performance and high price tag. For some, it's a masterpiece; for others, it's just an overpriced candle.

Favourite

Scent Profile

Citrus	13%	9%
Floral	21%	22%
Fruity	1%	6%
Green	11%	15%
Sweet	23%	20%
Warm	10%	14%
Woody	11%	8%
Earthy	9%	7%
Animalic	8%	3%
Fresh	18%	19%

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

Stetson EdP

Manhattan EdP

Notes

Shared Notes

Lavender 30% vs 38%

Bergamot 15% vs 29%

Only in Stetson

Clary Sage 22% Lemon 16% Lime 15%

Only in Manhattan

Basil 32%

Shared Notes

Jasmine 12% vs 16%

Only in Stetson

Carnation 19% Geranium 15% Cedar 14% Orris 14% Vetiver 13% Patchouli 12%

Only in Manhattan

Coconut 26% Heliotrope 21% Rose 19% Violet 18%

Shared Notes

Musk 21% vs 6%

Vanilla 18% vs 11%

Only in Stetson

Honey 22% Amber 21% Tonka Bean 17%

Only in Manhattan

Tobacco 12% Cinnamon 9% Clove 9% Pine 8% Benzoin 7% Vetiver 7% Ginger 7% Patchouli 6% Cedar 6% Pink Pepper 6% Oakmoss 6%

Accords

Stetson Manhattan

100%

Aromatic

75%

65%

Vanilla

100%

63%

Warm Spicy

90%

65%

Woody

82%

62%

Sweet

81%

Tobacco

78%

68%

Powdery

71%

68%

Floral

67%

Amber

61%

Fresh Spicy

62%

58%

Honey

Coconut

58%

Cinnamon

57%

Aromatic shared

100%

75%

Vanilla shared

65%

100%

Warm Spicy shared

63%

90%

Woody shared

65%

82%

Sweet shared

62%

81%

Tobacco

78%

Powdery shared

68%

71%

Floral

68%

Amber

67%

Fresh Spicy shared

61%

62%

Honey

58%

Coconut

58%

Cinnamon

57%

Performance

Stetson Manhattan

Moderate (4-6h)

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Moderate

Projection

Moderate

Intensity

Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Stetson

Seasons

Best For:

Autumn Winter

A cold-weather scent - best worn in autumn and winter.

Occasions

Best For:

Casual

Also Works:

Date

Its moderate sillage and comforting, sweet-powdery profile make it suitable for casual wear and some dates, especially in cooler weather, as many reviewers highlight its soothing qualities. However, its 'old-school' association and sweet warmth might be a bit much for formal events or offices, and it's definitely not one for the gym.

Manhattan

Seasons

Best For:

Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Spring

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Formal

Also Works:

Office Casual

Despite its dominant warm and spicy accords, many find Manhattan to be a surprisingly soft and subtle scent, making it suitable for office wear if applied lightly. Its luxurious and elegant profile, with emphasis on tobacco-vanilla, makes it ideal for evening and cooler weather occasions, particularly dates and formal events. However, its 'cozy' and sometimes 'candle-like' nature might not suit all formal settings, and its minimal sillage pushes it away from typical 'date night bombs'.