Malbec Black Eau de Parfum vs Secret of Success Eau de Parfum

Malbec Black

Edp	Concentration	Edp
U	Gender	U
2019	Year	2017
££	Price Tier	££

Secret of Success

ScentArt

A

Malbec Black

B

Secret of Success

Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Malbec Black

This one's a proper spicy enigma, constantly compared to Bvlgari Man in Black but confidently carving its own path. Expect a boozy, warm hug that's less uptight and surprisingly long-lasting, though perhaps a tad overhyped by some.

Acquired

Our Verdict - Secret of Success

This one's a divisive brew; some find it a unique, fizzy, cinnamon-tea delight, while others are left underwhelmed by its lack of heft or distinct character, especially given the price tag. Expect a journey from bright citrus to a warmer, spicier vanilla. It's either an addictive, innovative blend or just a bit... meh.

Favourite

Scent Profile

Citrus	11%	10%
Floral	12%	14%
Fruity	1%	3%
Green	20%	21%
Sweet	18%	27%
Warm	28%	31%
Woody	13%	3%
Earthy	8%	1%
Animalic	3%	2%
Fresh	18%	18%

Mood

Mood Energising

Calming

Character Playful

Serious

Sentiment Uplifting

Brooding

Malbec Black EdP

Secret of Success EdP

Notes

Shared Notes

Cinnamon 25% vs 40%

Only in Malbec Black

Cardamom 19% Ginger 15% Juniper 14% Lemon 14% Bergamot 13%

Only in Secret of Success

Grapefruit 30% Tea 30%

Only in Malbec Black

Sage 52% Geranium 48%

Only in Secret of Success

Rosemary 53% Ylang-Ylang 47%

Shared Notes

Vanilla 16% vs 48%

Only in Malbec Black

Sandalwood 15% Amber 15% Benzoin 15% Frankincense 14% Cashmeran 12% Patchouli 12%

Only in Secret of Success

Cardamom 51%

Accords

Malbec Black Secret of Success

100%

Warm Spicy

100%

94%

Amber

57%

Cinnamon

84%

78%

Woody

45%

65%

Aromatic

69%

62%

Vanilla

52%

62%

Fresh Spicy

58%

46%

Citrus

61%

60%

Powdery

49%

Balsamic

Green

48%

Warm Spicy shared

100%

Amber

94%

Cinnamon shared

57%

84%

Woody shared

78%

45%

Aromatic shared

65%

69%

Vanilla shared

62%

52%

Fresh Spicy shared

62%

58%

Citrus shared

46%

61%

Powdery

60%

Balsamic

49%

Green

48%

Performance

Malbec Black Secret of Success

Long (6-10h)

Longevity

Moderate (4-6h)

Strong

Projection

Moderate

Strong

Intensity

Moderate

Season and Occasion Fit

Malbec Black

Seasons

Best For:

Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Spring

A cold-weather scent - best worn in winter and autumn.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Formal

Also Works:

Casual

Its strong projection and longevity make it less suitable for the office, and the warmth is all wrong for sporty activities. This is a scent for intimate dates and evening wear, with its sophisticated spicy-woody character lending itself well to formal occasions.

Secret of Success

Seasons

Best For:

Autumn Winter

Also Works:

Spring Summer

Versatile across every season - no clear seasonal preference from wearers.

Occasions

Best For:

Date Casual

Also Works:

Office

Its moderate sillage and 'all-occasion' wearability, as mentioned by reviewers, make it versatile for both casual and office settings, leaning slightly more casual due to its playful spice. The warming cinnamon and vanilla accords suit dates well, but it might be too casual for very formal events. It's definitely not a sport scent.