A faithful budget echo of the lush jasmine-gourmand mood that defines Good Girl, recommended for wearers who want the creamy floral signature without the designer cost. Both compositions sit in the same modern white-floral-gourmand lane: juicy fruit and almond up front, jasmine and vanilla orchid in the heart, vanilla-sandalwood-musk base. The Carolina Herrera original layers in cocoa and tonka for a more decadent, evening-strength register that fills a room and holds eight-plus hours, with the iconic stiletto-shaped bottle adding to the special-occasion factor. The Artiscent version simplifies to the core jasmine-pear-vanilla register, holds five to six hours, and projects at arms-length rather than across the room. Pick Good Girl when you want the iconic gourmand-floral statement, the longer wear and the bottle as part of the experience. Pick Jasmine Nuit when you want the same creamy jasmine-vanilla mood for daily date and casual-evening wear at single-digit prices, accepting the simpler structure and shorter life.