Mirach is a divisive but ultimately beloved golden oud. While some find it too sweet or feminine, many celebrate its luxurious, clean take on the rose-oud combo, calling it a hidden gem for its quality and value at discounter prices.

Penhaligon's Halfeti pairs a dark rose against a leather-oud base for one of the house's most distinctive scents, and this dupe keeps the saffron-rose-oud spine intact. The patchouli-amber finish is warmer and less leathery than the original's, trading some of Halfeti's dry sophistication for a rounder, sweeter close.