Divisive, complex, and utterly intriguing, Back to Black is either a masterpiece of dark honeyed tobacco or a baby wipes and urinal cake nightmare. It's truly a love-it-or-hate-it scent that commands attention, for better or worse.

Rumkale Pine chases Penhaligon's Halfeti Cedar, a sweet, spiced cedar scent, and captures its arc: a saffron-peach-cardamom opening, a dried-fruit-and-cinnamon heart and a creamy cedar-vanilla base. The dupe flattens the original's rich, textured depth and trims its long sillage, wearing skin-close, but as a budget woody-spice it delivers the warm, slightly boozy cedar mood for a fraction of the price.