Dupe Pair
96%
Very Similar
Tommy Girl Eau de Toilette bottle Tommy Girl
Edt Concentration Edp
U Gender F
1996 Year 1996
££ Price Tier £
American Lady For Women Eau de Parfum bottle American Lady For Women

ScentArt

A
Tommy Girl
B
American Lady For Women
Full Screen Compare

Which Should You Buy?

Our Verdict - Tommy Girl
A throwback to the 90s, Tommy Girl is a divisive scent - some find it a timeless, fresh classic, others a dated, sharp reminder of school discos. Love it or hate it, you can't deny its place in perfume history. Still, it delivers a fresh, zesty punch that's hard to ignore.
Favourite
Our Verdict - American Lady For Women
A budget take on Tommy Hilfiger's 90s classic Tommy Girl. The crisp citrus-and-blackcurrant opening and clean green-floral heart of honeysuckle and violet capture the original's fresh, breezy spirit; like most PP dupes it reads a little flatter and gives up some of Tommy Girl's surprisingly good staying power.
Favourite

Scent Profile

Citrus Floral Fruity Green Sweet Warm Woody Earthy Animalic Fresh
Citrus 17% 19%
Floral 39% 40%
Fruity 12% 12%
Green 9% 14%
Sweet 18% 21%
Warm 1% 0%
Woody 11% 9%
Earthy 2% 2%
Animalic 6% 1%
Fresh 23% 20%

Mood

Mood Energising
Calming
Character Playful
Serious
Sentiment Uplifting
Brooding
Tommy Girl EdT
American Lady For Women EdP

Notes

Shared Notes
Apple Blossom 29% vs 21%
Mandarin 24% vs 19%
Camellia 24% vs 18%
Blackcurrant 21% vs 21%
Only in American Lady For Women
Tangerine 18%
Shared Notes
Honeysuckle 16% vs 27%
Grapefruit 14% vs 25%
Violet 10% vs 22%
Only in American Lady For Women
Green 24%
Shared Notes
Magnolia 23% vs 17%
Jasmine 22% vs 18%
Cedar 19% vs 17%
Sandalwood 17% vs 15%
Only in Tommy Girl
Leather 17%
Only in American Lady For Women
Rose 16% Lily 16%

Accords

Tommy Girl American Lady For Women
100%
Citrus
60%
85%
Floral
85%
60%
Fruity
70%
48%
Green
65%
56%
Aromatic
44%
Fresh
55%
50%
Rose
48%
Woody
45%
48%
Powdery
Citrus shared
100%
60%
Floral shared
85%
85%
Fruity shared
60%
70%
Green shared
48%
65%
56%
Fresh shared
44%
55%
50%
Woody shared
48%
45%
48%

Performance

Tommy Girl American Lady For Women
Moderate (4-6h)
Longevity
Short (2-4h)
Moderate
Projection
Intimate
Moderate
Intensity
Light

Season and Occasion Fit

Tommy Girl

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Summer

A warm-weather pick - at its best in summer and spring.

Occasions

Best For:
Office Casual Sport

Its clean, fresh character and moderate performance make it ideal for office, casual, and sport settings. Reviewers frequently mention its suitability for work and daytime activities, while its lack of traditional romance prevents it from being a good date night option.

American Lady For Women

Seasons

Best For:
Spring Summer

The crisp, green, citrus-floral character is built for warm weather, shining in spring and summer and feeling too light for the cold months.

Occasions

Best For:
Office Casual
Also Works:
Date Sport

A fresh, breezy everyday scent ideal for casual days, the office and light sport, easy enough to carry to daytime dates.

Similarity Breakdown

Overall
96%
Olfactory
98%
Notes
94%
Accord
77%
Key Similarities

Both share Floral, Fruity, Green accords and Camellia, Apple Blossom notes

Key Differences

Subtle differences in overall composition

Where to buy

Tommy Girl
American Lady For Women
also worth checking

ScentVerdict earns a commission from purchases - this doesn't affect our verdicts.

Compare Another Pair

VS