Quercia is a divisive one: a modern take on an old-school masculine fougère that swings from gorgeous complexity to synthetic mess, depending on who you ask. When it hits right, it's a classy, sensual head-turner, but the dry-down can be a gamble.

This one's a divisive freshie, plagued by reformulation rumours. The original was a unique herbal-spicy breath of fresh air; the new version, however, is a run-of-the-mill citrus cologne that disappoints fans and newcomers alike. Proceed with caution.