340 Good Girl

No. 340 sets out to recreate Carolina Herrera's Good Girl, a modern gourmand icon, and captures its duality of dark and floral fairly well. The opening pairs almond, coffee, bergamot and lemon for a rich, seductive introduction that closely echoes the original's contrast of bitter and sweet. The heart brings tuberose, jasmine sambac, orange blossom, rose and orris into a creamy floral bouquet reminiscent of the source, though it reads a touch simpler and less layered. The base is where the dupe piles on the sweetness, with tonka bean, cacao, vanilla, sandalwood, musk, amber, cedar and patchouli combining for a dense, sugary trail that leans thicker than the original's more polished gourmand finish. Glamorous and long-lasting by budget-fragrance standards, it's a solid pick for evening wear, though it won't match Good Girl's staying power or the sophistication of its blend across a full night out.