This one's a proper head-scratcher. While some reckon it's a stellar, fizzy gin and tonic for a luxurious summer, many others find it a generic, fleeting freshie, overpriced and synthetic to boot. Don't blind buy unless you like risk and disappointment.

Florence Man chases the cult dry incense-and-cedar austerity of Gucci Pour Homme 2003, and gets the smoky papyrus heart convincingly. The original's architectural depth and that smouldering-cigar leather facet come through thinner here, but for a budget tribute to a discontinued legend it reads honestly.